Plymouth Argyle
Sutton United
| FT 3 - 1 | ||
| 90'+2 |  H. Kasimu H. Beautyman | |
Morgan Whittaker  | 90'+1 | |
| L. Gibson M. Miller | 84' | |
| B. Waine R. Hardie | 77' | |
| K. Kesler-Hayden J. Edwards | 77' | |
| 73' | T. Fadahunsi L. Angol | |
| 73' | O. Patrick J. Coley | |
| Ryan Hardie | 68' | |
Joe Edwards  | 65' | |
| 64' | C. Eastmond D. Gape | |
| 64' | C. N'Guessan C. Clay | |
| 60' | Craig Clay | |
| J. Houghton C. Wright | 58' | |
| B. Mumba F. Issaka | 58' | |
| 50' | Lee Angol | |
| HT 1 - 0 | ||
| 34' | Joe Kizzi | |
| Luke Cundle | 18' | |
